Best perfumes inspired by Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco
1 affordable perfume inspired by Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco that Fragrantica voters find similar to it, ranked by a Bayesian score that combines the rating and the number of votes (a 4.6 with 80 votes does not beat a 4.4 with 5,000). The original: 4.39 on Fragrantica (698 votes). Fragrantica page Typical price of the original: $217 per 100 ml.
Amazon links are affiliate links: I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Sort by:
| # | Perfume | Score | Similarity | Typical price | Rating | Votes | Longevity | Sillage | Accords | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  | Tobacco RushAfnan · overall #315 | 4.23 | 68 % | $4280 % cheaper than the original | 4.20 | 328 | 3.8 | 2.7 | tobacco · woody · sweet · warm spicy | See on Amazon |
Pros: High-quality presentation and magnetic cap Cons: Not suitable for blind buying | |||||||||||
Similar originals
- Initio Parfums Prives Side Effect (2 alternatives)
- WIDIAN London (1 alternative)
- Mancera Red Tobacco (1 alternative)
- Nasomatto Black Afgano (2 alternatives)
- Tom Ford Black Orchid (2 alternatives)
- Rabanne 1 Million (2 alternatives)
How it works: data from Fragrantica (ratings, votes and the «This perfume reminds me of» yes/no votes). Score = (votes × rating + 1000 × 4.23) / (votes + 1000). Similarity = % of «yes». Typical price = today's US $ per 100 ml in US online shops (named, not linked); a rough guide, the Amazon price may differ. Updated 12/11/2026.